There are few household purchases as mundane, yet as critical, as toilet paper. It’s a silent workhorse of our daily lives, and we only ever truly notice it for two reasons: when it runs out, or when it’s terrible. I’ve been on what feels like a lifelong quest for the perfect balance—that elusive roll that is soft but not flimsy, strong but not scratchy, and lasts long enough that I’m not constantly playing a game of chicken with the last few sheets. The frustration of using a tissue that tears at the worst possible moment or feels like fine-grit sandpaper is a universal, albeit unspoken, annoyance. Conversely, stocking up on a brand that seems like a great deal only to find you’re using twice as much to get the job done is a betrayal of the budget. It’s this delicate dance of quality, quantity, and cost that led me to put the Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper to the test in our own home, hoping to find a definitive answer to this daily dilemma.
- IN THE BOX: 24 Mega Rolls (4 Packs of 6 Mega Rolls) equal to 120 regular rolls (based on a standard roll with 61 sheets)
- New manufacturing technology, same great quality, same sheet count
- SHEETS PER ROLL: with 308 2-ply sheets per roll of toilet paper
What to Consider Before Committing to a Case of Toilet Paper
Toilet paper is more than just an item on a shopping list; it’s a key solution for personal hygiene and household comfort. A good quality roll prevents waste, ensures cleanliness, and provides a small but significant touch of daily comfort. The main benefits of investing in a well-made product are efficiency (using fewer sheets), plumbing safety (proper dissolution), and user satisfaction. A poor choice can lead to plumbing issues, skin irritation, and the constant inconvenience of replacing rolls, turning a simple necessity into a recurring problem.
The ideal customer for a bulk package like this is typically a household manager for a family, a budget-conscious shopper who values performance, or anyone tired of making frequent trips to the store for a single item. It’s for people who want to “set it and forget it” for a month or two. On the other hand, this type of product might not be suitable for those who live in very small spaces with limited storage for a large case. It also may not satisfy individuals who demand the absolute peak of pillowy, lotion-infused softness found in ultra-premium luxury brands. For specialized needs, such as in an RV or boat, a more rapidly dissolving, single-ply paper might be a better, safer alternative.
Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:
- Dimensions & Space: Pay close attention to the roll size itself. “Mega Rolls” are thicker and wider in diameter than standard rolls and may not fit in all recessed or decorative toilet paper holders. Measure your holder’s clearance before buying in bulk. Also, consider the sheet dimensions—some brands have recently narrowed their sheets, which can be a point of contention for long-time users.
- Capacity/Performance: Look beyond the roll count. The key metrics are sheets per roll and ply count. A 2-ply tissue is generally stronger and softer than a 1-ply. The “regular roll equivalence” (e.g., “120 regular rolls”) can be a confusing marketing metric, so focusing on the 308 sheets per roll in this specific package gives you a more concrete number for comparison.
- Materials & Durability: The source of the paper pulp matters for both performance and environmental impact. We look for certifications like FSC (Forest Stewardship Council) or PEFC, which confirm the materials are sourced from sustainably managed forests. “Ultra-Strong” claims should be backed by a thick, well-bonded 2-ply construction that resists tearing and linting.
- Ease of Use & Maintenance: The most important factor here is whether the toilet paper is “septic-safe.” Using a non-septic-safe tissue can lead to catastrophic and expensive plumbing problems down the line. Additionally, consider the amount of lint or “TP dust” a roll produces, as excessive lint can be messy and irritating for some users.
While the Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper is an excellent choice for many households, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, especially those catering to specific needs like sensitivity, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:
- WHAT’S INCLUDED — 12 Double Rolls of Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 1-ply, 231 sheets per roll, 291.60 square feet total (12 double rolls = 24 regular rolls)
- SHIPMENT CONTAINS: 30 Rolls with 350 2-ply sheets per roll for a total of 10,500 sheets
- Packaging Information: our package contains 4 rolls of Christmas themed toilet paper, our Christmas toilet paper is made of three-ply toilet paper, soft and durable, moderate thickness, the paper is...
First Impressions and Unboxing the Presto! Experience
The Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper arrives in a large, unassuming cardboard box. Inside, the 24 rolls are neatly bundled into four separate plastic packs of six, which I immediately appreciated for storage. It’s much easier to tuck away a six-pack under a sink or in a linen closet than to deal with a cascade of loose rolls. Upon opening the first pack, my initial impression was one of substance. The rolls felt dense and heavy, a good sign for longevity. The embossing pattern, a simple floral-like design, is subtle and pleasant. Squeezing the roll, it had a firm give—not pillowy soft like some luxury brands, but certainly not stiff or coarse. There was no discernible scent, confirming its “unscented” claim, which is a major plus for our household. Placing a roll next to the Charmin Ultra Strong we were finishing up, the Presto! roll looked comparable in diameter, a promising start for a brand that competes heavily on value. You can see its full specifications and user photos online to get a better sense of its size.
What We Like
- Excellent strength and durability; resists tearing when in use.
- Thick 2-ply construction feels substantial and effective.
- Septic-safe and certified from sustainable sources (FSC & PEFC).
- Great value proposition, especially when compared to premium name brands.
Drawbacks
- Numerous long-time users report “shrinkflation,” with newer rolls being smaller and narrower.
- Some recent batches have been noted to produce more lint and dust than previously.
A Deep Dive into Presto! Toilet Paper’s Performance
A product used every single day demands more than a cursory glance. It requires rigorous, real-world testing. We integrated the Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper into all the bathrooms in our home for several weeks, evaluating it on the key pillars of performance: strength, comfort, value, and overall practicality. What we discovered was a product with a stellar performance record, but one that is also at the center of a contentious debate among its most loyal users.
Strength and Durability: Does “Ultra-Strong” Hold Up?
The primary claim on the packaging is “Ultra-Strong,” and in our testing, this was not an exaggeration. The 2-ply sheets are thick and robustly bonded together. We performed the classic “wet strength” test, holding a dampened sheet and seeing how much pressure it could take before tearing, and it performed admirably. In practical, everyday use, this translates to reliability. There were no instances of the dreaded tear-through or disintegration. As one user aptly put it, they were a fan because the paper “doesn’t disintegrate when wet.” This strength means you can use fewer sheets per visit, which directly impacts how long a roll lasts. We found ourselves unconsciously using less than we did with thinner, less reliable brands. This performance is particularly noticeable when you compare it to competitors. One convert noted their shock at the difference, stating, “I didn’t realize how thick the sheets of Presto! were until we had to use the paper thin Charmin.” This durability is a feature that truly sets it apart in its price category, delivering a premium-brand feel of security and effectiveness without the premium price tag.
Softness and Comfort: A Surprising Contender
When you hear “Ultra-Strong,” the mind often jumps to “rough” or “industrial.” That simply isn’t the case here. While the Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper doesn’t have the silky, lotion-infused feel of the most luxurious brands on the market, it is surprisingly soft. The texture is pleasant against the skin, and the thickness contributes to a feeling of comfort and quality. We found it strikes an excellent balance, providing what one user described as “very substantial for the ‘dirty jobs’ as well as nice and soft for the ‘lighter jobs’.” This is the sweet spot many families are looking for. It’s gentle enough for everyone in the household, and the unscented formulation is a critical feature for those with sensitive skin or allergies. There are no added dyes or perfumes to cause irritation. In a blind test, members of my family guessed it was a more expensive, well-known brand, which speaks volumes about its perceived quality. For those looking to move away from pricier options without a significant downgrade in comfort, this is a compelling choice. As another happy customer noted, “This toilet paper is actually slightly softer than the brand I normally get! It seems to be better Quality and a lot Cheaper!”
Value and Longevity: The Contentious Math of the Mega Roll
This is where our review gets complicated. On paper, the value proposition is fantastic. A pack of 24 Mega Rolls, touted as equivalent to 120 regular rolls, seems designed to last a family for a very long time. And indeed, each roll, with its 308 sheets, has impressive longevity. However, a significant and vocal contingent of long-time, repeat buyers has raised the alarm about “shrinkflation.” The evidence they present is compelling, often with side-by-side photos showing older Presto! rolls next to new ones. One user who has purchased the product 26 times lamented, “This time unfortunately I noticed the roll was considerably smaller.” Another provided photographic proof, saying, “The new package is on the left. The old is on the right. New is smaller…The new version are shorter.” The complaints center on two things: the overall diameter of the roll has shrunk, and the width of the individual sheets is now narrower. This is a classic case of a company reducing the product size while keeping the price stable or even increasing it. While the sheet count of 308 remains the same, the total square footage per package has reportedly decreased in newer batches. This doesn’t negate the product’s inherent quality—it’s still strong and soft—but it does undermine the trust of loyal customers and makes the value calculation murkier. For a new buyer, the value is still likely better than major brands. But for those who have been buying for years, the change is a significant drawback. It’s a situation that warrants careful consideration, and we recommend you check the latest price and user reviews to make your own determination on value.
Practical Considerations: Lint, Septic Safety, and Sustainability
Beyond the core functions, a few practical details stood out. The Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper is explicitly labeled as septic-safe, a non-negotiable feature for our home and for most modern plumbing systems. We experienced no issues with flushing or drainage during our testing period. One user even performed a “dissolve test” for their camper, finding that it broke down well and was a great choice for their RV toilet. This versatility is a huge plus. On the environmental front, the FSC and PEFC certifications are commendable, assuring us that the paper pulp comes from responsibly managed forests. However, there is a recurring complaint in recent reviews about lint. One user stated, “As you pull it out, there is a cloud of lint in the air.” While we didn’t experience a “cloud,” we did notice a bit more dust and lint left on the roll holder than with some other premium brands. It wasn’t a dealbreaker for us, but for individuals particularly sensitive to dust or who prioritize a pristine bathroom, it’s a point to consider. This seems to be a more recent quality control issue, potentially linked to the other changes in manufacturing.
What Other Users Are Saying
Synthesizing the user feedback for the Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper reveals a clear divide between long-term customers and new converts. The overriding positive sentiment, especially from first-time buyers, focuses on the product’s incredible performance for its price. One reviewer summed it up perfectly: “I received Presto Ultra Strong toilet paper today for the first time… I would say that these both of these products [Presto and Cottonelle] are compatible in quality. However, Presto far outweighs Cottonelle in value.” Many, like the user who switched from Kirkland after 15 years, are “extremely surprised in a good way.”
However, the negative feedback is just as passionate and centers almost exclusively on the recent changes to the product. The term “shrinkflation” appears repeatedly. A loyal customer who had the product on subscription for years posted a photo comparison and said, “They shrunk the rolls (smaller size squares and less sqft/roll) yet now they claim that one pkg equals 30 regular rolls when the previous larger rolls only ‘equaled’ 24… interesting.” Another user was more blunt: “This is a huge ripoff and unless they change back to the original formula, my family will no longer purchasing Presto toilet paper.” This feedback is critical because it speaks to a change in the value proposition that made the product so popular in the first place.
How Does Presto! Compare to the Alternatives?
No product exists in a vacuum. To understand its place in the market, we need to compare the Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper against a few key alternatives, each serving a different purpose.
1. Camco 4-Roll RV Toilet Paper Quick Dissolve
- Designed for RV/Marine Use: Keep your system running reliably and smoothly with this specially engineered marine and RV toilet paper. This RV accessory is a camper must-have— add this great product...
- Clog-Resistant: Say goodbye to those unexpected surprises! This rapid-dissolving toilet paper quickly flushes away without clogging, thanks to its fast-dissolving formula.
- 1-Ply Protection: 1-ply toilet paper Protection offers a soft, yet resilient feel— leaving you feeling confident and refreshed after every use.
The Camco RV Toilet Paper is a specialty product designed for a specific, critical need: use in RV, marine, or other sensitive septic systems where rapid dissolution is paramount. It is a 1-ply tissue that breaks down extremely quickly to prevent clogs. Compared to the Presto! roll, the Camco paper is significantly thinner and less soft. Someone might prefer this alternative if their primary or sole concern is plumbing safety in a non-standard system. For everyday household use, however, the strength, softness, and overall comfort of the 2-ply Presto! paper is far superior.
2. Boardwalk 2-Ply Bathroom Toilet Paper 96 Rolls
- Individually wrapped, soft, two-ply, textured, perforated toilet tissue.
- Embossed, standard size toilet paper roll.
- Economical, reliable and septic safe.
Boardwalk represents the bulk, commercial-grade option. Sold in a massive 96-roll carton, its primary appeal is sheer quantity and a low per-sheet cost. This is the kind of toilet paper you’d find in an office building or public restroom. While it is 2-ply and septic-safe, it generally lacks the softness and thickness of a consumer-focused brand like Presto!. A facilities manager or someone stocking a multi-family property would prefer Boardwalk for its economy of scale. A household that prioritizes comfort and a more premium feel would find the Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper to be a much more satisfying choice for daily use.
3. Angel Soft 16 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper
- Every roll of Angel Soft Toilet Paper delivers a heavenly combination of softness and strength you can count on every time.
- Each Mega Roll is equal to 4 Angel Soft Regular Rolls, so you can change the toilet paper rolls less often
- Mega Rolls deliver the long-lasting toilet paper rolls you need at a price you’ll love. How divine!
Angel Soft is a direct and well-known competitor in the consumer market, famous for its brand promise of being both soft and strong. It sits in a similar price and quality tier as Presto!, making it a very relevant comparison. Angel Soft has strong brand recognition and a loyal following. The choice between Angel Soft and Presto! often comes down to personal preference in texture and sale pricing. Historically, Presto! offered a slightly better value, but with the recent “shrinkflation” issues, that gap has narrowed. A shopper might prefer Angel Soft if they are a long-time fan of its particular feel or if they are wary of the reported quality control changes with the Presto! brand.
The Final Verdict: A Great Product with a Catch
After weeks of testing and poring over user feedback, our verdict on the Presto! 24 Mega Rolls Toilet Paper is one of qualified recommendation. At its core, this is an excellent product. It is genuinely strong, surprisingly soft, septic-safe, and made with sustainable practices. For a first-time buyer switching from a more expensive name brand, the quality and performance will likely be a delightful and budget-friendly surprise. It effectively delivers on its promises of a reliable and comfortable clean.
However, the shadow of “shrinkflation” looms large. The consistent reports from long-time customers about smaller, narrower rolls cannot be ignored and tarnish what was once an unbeatable value. While still a solid performer, it is no longer the runaway bargain it used to be. We recommend it to families and value-conscious shoppers who prioritize strength and performance, but with the caveat that you should be aware of these recent changes. If you’re seeking a durable, no-nonsense toilet paper that gets the job done well and are new to the brand, you will almost certainly be satisfied. To see if the current value proposition works for your household, we highly encourage you to check the latest price and read the most recent user feedback for yourself.
Last update on 2025-11-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API