There are few household purchases as routine, yet as critical, as toilet paper. We’ve all been there: standing in the aisle, overwhelmed by a wall of plastic-wrapped promises. “Ultra-soft,” “ultra-strong,” “double rolls,” “mega rolls”—the marketing jargon is endless. The goal is simple: find a toilet paper that is soft, durable, and doesn’t require a second mortgage to stock up on. For years, my family and I thought we had found the holy grail. A product that offered premium, brand-name softness and longevity at a price that made sense for a busy household. It became an auto-ship staple, one less thing to worry about. But as many loyal users have discovered, the landscape can shift beneath your feet, forcing a re-evaluation of a product you once championed. This review is for anyone caught in that familiar cycle, wondering if their trusted go-to still holds up.
- SHIPMENT CONTAINS: 24 Mega Rolls (4 Packs of 6 Mega Rolls) with 308 2-ply sheets per roll
- New manufacturing technology, same great quality, same sheet count
- ULTRA SOFT: Leaves less lint behind (versus the leading Ultra-Premium Soft Brand, based on laboratory testing)
What to Consider Before You Buy Bulk Toilet Paper
Toilet paper is more than just an item on a shopping list; it’s a key solution for daily hygiene, comfort, and household management. Choosing the right one prevents a host of minor but significant annoyances: the frustration of a roll that runs out too quickly, the discomfort of rough or thin paper, and the plumbing nightmares that can result from a product that isn’t septic-safe. The main benefits of finding the right bulk toilet paper are cost savings, convenience, and the peace of mind that comes from being well-stocked. It reduces frequent trips to the store and ensures you’re not caught empty-handed, which, as we’ve all learned, can be a major stressor.
The ideal customer for a bulk product like the Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper is typically a family or a multi-person household looking to balance quality with long-term value. They appreciate softness and strength but are also budget-conscious. This product might not be suitable for those with extremely limited storage space, as a case of 24 mega rolls takes up considerable room. It’s also not designed for specialized needs like RV or marine septic systems, for which quick-dissolving, single-ply options are often recommended. If you fall into those latter categories, you might consider more specialized alternatives.
Before investing in a large supply, consider these crucial points in detail:
- Roll Size & Sheet Count: Pay close attention to terms like “Mega,” “Family,” or “Jumbo.” These are not standardized across brands. The most important metrics are the number of sheets per roll and the total square footage per package. A “Family Mega Roll” with 308 sheets, like this one, is designed to last significantly longer, reducing the frequency of roll changes.
- Ply and Softness: Ply refers to the number of layers of paper. A 2-ply paper, like Presto!, is generally softer and stronger than a 1-ply. The texture and embossing pattern also contribute significantly to the perceived softness and cleaning effectiveness. Some ultra-premium brands may even offer 3-ply, but 2-ply often provides the best balance of comfort and value.
- Strength & Durability: A good toilet paper should be strong enough to do its job without tearing, shredding, or leaving lint behind. This is where quality really shows. Laboratory tests often measure wet strength to determine durability, a factor that directly impacts how much you need to use per visit.
- Septic System Compatibility: This is non-negotiable for most homeowners. Ensure the toilet paper is labeled as “septic-safe.” This means it’s designed to break down efficiently in a standard septic system, preventing costly blockages and plumbing issues. All reputable brands should meet this standard for household use.
Understanding these factors will empower you to look past the marketing and choose a product that truly meets your household’s needs for comfort, performance, and value.
While the Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper has been a top contender for years, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:
- WHAT’S INCLUDED — 12 Double Rolls of Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 1-ply, 231 sheets per roll, 291.60 square feet total (12 double rolls = 24 regular rolls)
- SHIPMENT CONTAINS: 30 Rolls with 350 2-ply sheets per roll for a total of 10,500 sheets
- Packaging Information: our package contains 4 rolls of Christmas themed toilet paper, our Christmas toilet paper is made of three-ply toilet paper, soft and durable, moderate thickness, the paper is...
First Impressions: A Tale of Two Products
Unboxing our latest shipment of the Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper was a different experience than it used to be. For years, the arrival of this large, surprisingly heavy box meant we were set for months. The product itself, once freed from its plastic wrap, was impressively plush. Each roll felt dense and substantial, with a soft, quilted texture that rivaled—and in our opinion, often surpassed—the leading premium brands. It was strong, comfortable, and left virtually no lint behind, which was a major selling point.
However, our most recent delivery immediately felt… off. The shipping box was noticeably smaller, a sentiment echoed by many long-time users. Inside, the four packs of six rolls seemed more compact. Upon placing a new roll on the holder next to an old one, the difference was undeniable. The new roll was visibly narrower. While the packaging claims the same sheet count and square footage, the tactile experience has changed. The paper feels slightly less plush, and the rolls are not as tightly wound as they once were. This was the product we’d loved for years, but it felt like we were meeting a different, less impressive version of it. You can see the full product specifications and details for yourself on the product page.
What We Like
- Excellent softness that historically competed with top-tier brands.
- Mega roll format provides great value and longevity, reducing roll changes.
- Septic-safe and certified for energy savings, adding peace of mind.
- Unscented and 2-ply design is suitable for most users.
What We Didn’t Like
- Recent changes have resulted in smaller, narrower rolls.
- Perceived decrease in softness, thickness, and overall quality.
A Deep Dive into the Presto! Performance: Then and Now
To truly understand the Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper, we have to look at it from two perspectives: the product that earned a loyal following, and the product that is being shipped today. Our extensive testing over the years gives us a unique vantage point to analyze the shifts in quality and performance and determine if it still represents the incredible value it once did.
Softness & Comfort: The Original Premium Feel
The original reason we, and so many others, switched to this brand was its exceptional softness. The “Ultra-Soft” label wasn’t just marketing; it was a reality. The paper had a luxurious, cushiony feel without being overly thick or pillowy, striking a perfect balance. It was gentle on the skin and felt every bit as premium as Charmin Ultra Soft, which was our previous go-to. As one long-time user fondly recalled, “This used to be our favorite toilet paper for years; refused to use anything else if we could avoid it since it was the softest and strongest.” This sentiment was the cornerstone of the product’s success. It delivered a luxury experience at a non-luxury price point. We consistently found it to be comfortable and effective, a combination that is surprisingly hard to find.
Unfortunately, our latest batch tells a different story. The texture has changed. While it is still soft by general standards—certainly better than “gas station” or bargain-bin brands—it has lost that signature plushness. The embossing seems shallower, and the paper feels a touch thinner. A user who recently updated their review captured this perfectly: “they clearly changed their manufacturer and it’s a completely different product (pattern and texture are both different… I liked how soft it was before but this is too rough now.” It no longer feels like a direct competitor to the top-tier brands. It now sits more comfortably in the mid-range category, which is a disappointment for those of us who were accustomed to its former glory. You can check the latest price and availability to see if the value proposition still works for you.
Strength, Durability, and the Lint Test
Beyond softness, a toilet paper’s primary job is to be strong and effective. The Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper has always performed well in this regard. Its 2-ply construction held together beautifully, preventing the dreaded tear-through that plagues lesser brands. One of its standout features was its claim to “leave less lint behind,” and in our experience, this was absolutely true. It was clean, efficient, and didn’t disintegrate during use. You could use fewer sheets and feel confident, which contributed to the overall value and longevity of each roll.
The new version, however, shows some weakness here. We’ve noticed the two plies can separate more easily, especially when starting a new roll. As one user noted, “It’s difficult to get the roll started. You end up tearing off multiple layers just to get it usable.” We experienced this ourselves, with the first few sheets shredding before we could get a clean start. Furthermore, because the paper feels thinner, we find ourselves subconsciously using more sheets to compensate. “I now feel like I need to use 6 or 7 squares instead of 4,” a reviewer lamented, and we can confirm this psychological—and practical—shift. While it remains a functional and reasonably strong paper, it has lost the robust, reliable feel that once set it apart.
The “Shrinkflation” Dilemma: Roll Size and Overall Value
This is, without a doubt, the most significant and widely discussed change to the Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper. The phenomenon of “shrinkflation”—where the product size shrinks but the price stays the same or increases—appears to be at play here. Our direct comparison of an old roll from a previous order and a new one from our latest shipment confirmed what countless users have photographed and reported: the new rolls are narrower by a noticeable margin, roughly an inch.
This change has a direct impact on the value proposition. The packaging still boasts that 24 Family Mega Rolls are equivalent to 120 regular rolls, based on a 66-sheet regular roll. While the sheet count per roll remains 308, the smaller sheet width means the total square footage per package has decreased, even if the packaging hasn’t been updated to reflect it. As one skeptical user rightly pointed out, “I find it hard to believe the package total sq ft is the same… when it is clear about an inch of total width has been lost.” This feels like a cost-cutting measure that undermines the trust of long-term customers. The value was always in getting a premium product for less. Now, you’re getting a lesser product for a similar or even higher price, which erodes its competitive edge entirely. This is a critical factor for anyone considering making a bulk purchase, and it’s worth weighing the current cost against this reduced product size.
What Other Users Are Saying
The user feedback for this product paints a clear and consistent picture of its evolution. The overwhelming sentiment is one of past satisfaction clashing with present disappointment. For years, reviews were glowing. One satisfied customer summed up the classic experience: “I was really impressed with this toilet paper. It’s incredibly soft… it doesn’t fall apart easily… it’s very affordable… It strikes a great balance between quality and value—definitely a household staple for me.” Another compared it favorably to a major brand, stating it was a “game changer” after being a “snob” who would only use Charmin.
However, recent reviews are dominated by the changes. A very common complaint is that “the rolls are now smaller, but also the texture has changed. It is thinner, less textured, not as soft, and the two ply separates.” Another long-time buyer put it bluntly: “Presto changed their product to a lesser quality. Not happy with the change and will likely switch brands.” There are also occasional reports of quality control issues, such as a user who found “some of my rolls were dirty before I opened the plastic packaging” or another who had a package arrive with missing rolls. This shift in feedback is crucial for potential buyers; we recommend you read through the most recent user reviews to get a real-time sense of customer satisfaction.
How Does Presto! Stack Up Against the Alternatives?
While the Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper is undergoing changes, it’s important to see how it compares to other options on the market, each serving a different primary need.
1. Georgia-Pacific Angel Soft Professional 2-Ply Toilet Paper 36 Rolls
- PREMIUM QUALITY embossed toilet paper that provides soft, reliable performance
- CORELESS ROLLS let you use 100% of the toilet paper and eliminate stub roll waste
- HIGH CAPACITY roll drives fewer roll changes and lowers maintenance costs
The Georgia-Pacific Angel Soft Professional series is aimed more at commercial or high-traffic residential use. Its biggest selling point is the sheer volume: 750 sheets per coreless roll, and 36 rolls per case. This is a workhorse product designed for maximum capacity and minimal changes. Compared to the Presto! paper, the Angel Soft Professional is likely not as soft or plush; it prioritizes function and longevity over a luxurious feel. Someone who runs a small business, manages a property, or simply wants to buy toilet paper as infrequently as humanly possible would prefer this option. However, for everyday family comfort, the Presto! paper, even in its current form, offers a softer experience.
2. Camco 4-Roll RV Toilet Paper Quick Dissolve
- Designed for RV/Marine Use: Keep your system running reliably and smoothly with this specially engineered marine and RV toilet paper. This RV accessory is a camper must-have— add this great product...
- Clog-Resistant: Say goodbye to those unexpected surprises! This rapid-dissolving toilet paper quickly flushes away without clogging, thanks to its fast-dissolving formula.
- 1-Ply Protection: 1-ply toilet paper Protection offers a soft, yet resilient feel— leaving you feeling confident and refreshed after every use.
The Camco RV & Marine toilet paper is a highly specialized product. It’s a 1-ply tissue designed to dissolve extremely quickly to protect sensitive RV, marine, or non-standard septic systems. This is its entire purpose. In a direct comparison, it will be significantly thinner and less soft than the 2-ply Presto! paper. There is no contest in terms of comfort. However, using a standard household toilet paper like Presto! in an RV could lead to catastrophic clogs and tank sensor issues. Therefore, the Camco paper is not an alternative for home use but an essential purchase for its target audience of RVers and boaters.
3. AmazonCommercial RV & Marine Toilet Paper 24 Rolls
- Our premium 2-ply quick disperse toilet tissue is soft, strong, highly absorbent and compatible with waste tanks
- Each bulk family pack contains 24 Rolls, 300 Sheets per Roll, for a total of 7,200 sheets
- 2-ply virgin fiber for superior softness, strength, and quick absorbency; quilted texture for added comfort; gentle on skin of all sensitivity levels
Similar to the Camco product, this AmazonCommercial option is engineered for RV and marine use. It’s a 2-ply paper, which may give it a slight edge in softness and strength over the 1-ply Camco, but it is still designed for rapid dissolving. It is FSC certified, ensuring it comes from responsibly managed forests. Against the Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper, it will feel less substantial and is not intended for standard home plumbing where rapid dissolving isn’t the primary concern. This is another case where the choice is dictated entirely by the type of plumbing system you have, making it a necessary item for travelers rather than a direct competitor for home use.
The Final Verdict: Is Presto! Toilet Paper Still a Smart Buy?
After years of being one of our top household recommendations, our verdict on the Presto! 24 Family Mega Rolls Toilet Paper is now a qualified one. The product that once offered an unbeatable combination of premium softness, excellent strength, and outstanding value has changed. The recent reduction in roll width and the noticeable step down in plushness and texture mean it no longer competes directly with the top-tier luxury brands it once did.
So, who should buy it? If you are a new customer who never experienced the “original” version, you may find this to be a perfectly adequate mid-tier toilet paper that offers good value in a bulk format. It is still soft, reasonably strong, and septic-safe. However, for the legion of loyal fans who fell in love with its former quality, the current product may feel like a disappointment. It has shifted from being a premium-alternative to a standard store-brand equivalent. Our recommendation is to approach this purchase with adjusted expectations. It’s no longer the undisputed champion of value, but a contender among many. Before committing to a large case, we strongly advise you to check the current price and read the very latest user reviews to make the most informed decision for your family.
Last update on 2025-11-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API