For years, my household operated on a simple, unspoken rule: buy the softest, plushest, most cloud-like toilet paper on the shelf. It was a small, daily luxury. But a nagging cognitive dissonance began to set in. We were diligently recycling, composting, and reducing plastic use in every other corner of our home, yet this one essential item remained a glaring contradiction. We were, quite literally, flushing pristine forests down the toilet for a fleeting moment of comfort. The search for an alternative felt daunting. Early eco-friendly options we tried were, frankly, terrible—thin, scratchy, and reminiscent of industrial-grade sandpaper. It felt like we had to choose between our comfort and our conscience. This is the dilemma that led us to investigate the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper, a product that promises to deliver on quality, sustainability, and social good. The question was, could it truly break the cycle of compromise?
- PREMIUM BAMBOO TOILET PAPER: Our fanciest toilet paper rolls are luxuriously soft and ultra-strong, and made with extra cushy double length 3 ply rolls. Who Gives A Crap bathroom tissue plays well...
- 3 PLY SOFT TOILET PAPER: Our extra cushy bath tissue might feel a bit different since, well, it is a bit different. Unlike most blanket-like mainstream TP, these rolls aren’t made with virgin trees....
- 100% BAMBOO FIBERS: Every day, over 1 million trees are cut down to make traditional toilet paper. We’re not so keen on killing trees just to make TP, which is why these rolls are made with 100%...
What to Consider Before Committing to a New Toilet Paper
A toilet paper is more than just an item; it’s a key solution for daily hygiene, personal comfort, and, increasingly, a reflection of our environmental values. The right choice can prevent skin irritation, ensure your plumbing and septic system remain healthy, and reduce your household’s ecological footprint. A premium product offers a blend of strength, so it doesn’t tear or leave residue behind, and softness, which is crucial for sensitive skin. Furthermore, with options like bamboo, it provides a sustainable alternative to traditional tree-pulp paper, directly addressing concerns about deforestation.
The ideal customer for this type of product is someone who is eco-conscious and actively seeking ways to reduce their environmental impact without sacrificing quality. They are often consumers who read labels, care about a company’s ethics—in this case, donating 50% of profits to sanitation projects—and may have sensitive skin that reacts poorly to the chemicals, dyes, and fragrances in conventional brands. It’s for the person who sees their purchasing power as a tool for positive change. Conversely, this might not be the best fit for those on a very strict budget, as eco-friendly options often carry a higher price tag. It’s also likely not for the user whose sole priority is achieving the absolute pinnacle of pillowy softness found in luxury brands like Charmin, as bamboo offers a different, though equally effective, texture. For those buyers, a traditional mega-roll might still be the preferred, albeit less sustainable, choice.
Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:
- Dimensions & Space: Pay close attention to the roll size, sheet count, and sheet dimensions. The Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper boasts 330 sheets per roll, qualifying them as “double length.” This means fewer roll changes, but you should also note recent user feedback suggesting potential changes in roll width or height. Ensure the rolls will fit your existing holder and that you have adequate storage space for a 24-roll pack.
- Capacity/Performance: Performance in toilet paper is a balance of softness, strength, and absorbency. A 3-ply construction, as featured here, is a premium standard that provides durability and prevents breakthrough. Bamboo fibers are naturally strong and absorbent, meaning you can often use less paper per visit compared to thinner, 1- or 2-ply options.
- Materials & Durability: This product is made from 100% bamboo fibers. Unlike trees, which can take decades to mature, bamboo is a fast-growing grass that can be harvested annually, making it a highly renewable and sustainable resource. It’s also biodegradable and septic-safe, ensuring it breaks down properly and won’t cause plumbing issues, a critical factor for many homeowners.
- Ease of Use & Maintenance: The key factor here is skin compatibility. Bamboo toilet paper is naturally hypoallergenic and is made without the harsh chlorine, inks, dyes, or fragrances found in many conventional brands. This makes it an exceptional choice for individuals with sensitive skin or allergies, as it significantly reduces the risk of irritation and leaves behind no “lint” or dust. You can see the full material specifications and hypoallergenic claims here.
Making a thoughtful choice in this category can elevate a daily necessity into a conscious act that benefits your home, your health, and the planet.
While the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper is an excellent choice, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:
- WHAT’S INCLUDED — 12 Double Rolls of Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 1-ply, 231 sheets per roll, 291.60 square feet total (12 double rolls = 24 regular rolls)
- SHIPMENT CONTAINS: 30 Rolls with 350 2-ply sheets per roll for a total of 10,500 sheets
- Packaging Information: our package contains 4 rolls of Christmas themed toilet paper, our Christmas toilet paper is made of three-ply toilet paper, soft and durable, moderate thickness, the paper is...
Unboxing an Experience: First Impressions of Who Gives A Crap
Our delivery arrived not in a plastic-wrapped bundle, but in a simple, brown cardboard box—the first sign of the brand’s commitment to sustainability. Opening it revealed the product’s signature feature: 24 individually wrapped rolls, each adorned with a unique, colorful, and often humorous pattern. There’s an immediate sense that this isn’t just toilet paper; it’s a statement piece for your bathroom. Many users we surveyed agreed, with one noting, “I love this toilet paper! It is wrapped beautifully and looks so much better than regular tp… I love it in my guest bathroom and I am always asked about it.”
The paper wrappers serve a dual purpose: they keep the rolls clean and hygienic without plastic, and they turn a mundane stack of TP into a decorative element. Unwrapping the first roll, we found the paper itself has a substantial feel. It’s not fluffy or pillowy in the way of a luxury quilted brand, but it feels dense and strong. The 3-ply construction is immediately evident, and the paper has a subtle texture. It feels practical and reliable, a tool designed to do its job effectively rather than just be soft. This initial impression aligns perfectly with the brand’s no-nonsense, high-impact ethos. You can check the latest price and see the vibrant packaging designs for yourself.
Key Benefits
- Made from 100% sustainable and renewable bamboo
- Company donates 50% of profits to clean water and sanitation projects
- Strong, durable, and lint-free 3-ply construction
- Hypoallergenic and free of inks, dyes, and fragrances, making it ideal for sensitive skin
- Completely plastic-free packaging
Limitations
- Not as pillowy-soft as premium, tree-pulp-based luxury brands
- Some long-term users have reported a reduction in roll size over time
A Detailed Breakdown: How WGAC Performs Where It Counts
After several weeks of using the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper in a busy household, we’ve developed a comprehensive understanding of its performance across several key areas. This isn’t just about how it feels on the first use, but how it holds up over time, how it impacts our home’s systems, and whether its ethical promises translate into a product worth its premium price.
The Softness vs. Strength Equation
The most immediate point of comparison for any toilet paper is the balance between softness and strength. Let’s be clear: if you are expecting the cloud-like, artificially softened feel of a brand like Charmin, this is not that. The Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper offers a different kind of quality. The bamboo fibers create a paper that is exceptionally strong and resilient. During our testing, we experienced zero instances of tearing, shredding, or leaving behind lint—a common complaint with both ultra-plush and budget brands. As one satisfied user put it, “Out of all the eco friendly brands ive tried before, this is the best. It doesn’t fall apart, you don’t have to use tons.”
This strength means you use fewer sheets, which helps offset the initial cost and extends the life of each roll. The softness is best described as “natural” and sufficient. It’s not scratchy or abrasive in any way; it’s simply not fluffy. The 3-ply design gives it a pleasant thickness and a textured surface that cleans effectively. We found it perfectly comfortable for daily use, and its reliability quickly became its most appreciated feature. It’s a workhorse toilet paper that provides confidence and cleanliness, prioritizing functional performance over artificial plushness. This is a product for those who define quality by durability and effectiveness, not just by how it feels in the package.
A Champion for Sensitive Skin and Septic Systems
This is where the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper truly shines and earns its place as a premium product. For households with individuals prone to skin irritation, this toilet paper can be a game-changer. Conventional toilet papers are often bleached with chlorine and contain additives like scents, lotions, and dyes that can cause significant discomfort. One user’s dramatic testimony highlights this perfectly: “I have such sensitive skin that every other brand burns my flesh. Thick Cottonelle or Charmin burn my skin and leave lint behind that will also end up burning skin.”
Our experience confirms this. The paper is clean, pure, and free of any perceptible chemical scent. Because it’s made from bamboo, it doesn’t require the same harsh processing as wood pulp, resulting in a naturally hypoallergenic product. It’s gentle and non-irritating, a quality we found consistently reliable. Furthermore, its performance is lint-free, preventing the annoying and potentially irritating residue left by other brands. For anyone who has struggled with skin sensitivity, the value of a product like this cannot be overstated. Beyond personal comfort, it’s also designed to be septic-safe. The biodegradable bamboo fibers break down easily, preventing clogs and ensuring compatibility with home plumbing and septic tanks, providing crucial peace of mind for homeowners. This feature alone makes it a worthwhile investment for many.
The Eco-Conscious and Ethical Impact
A significant part of this product’s value proposition lies beyond the roll itself. By choosing the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper, consumers are actively participating in a more sustainable and ethical model. The environmental benefits of using bamboo are immense. As a grass, it grows incredibly fast and requires far less water and land than trees, all while sequestering carbon. This directly combats the deforestation associated with the traditional paper industry.
The brand’s commitment extends to its packaging, which is 100% plastic-free. From the cardboard shipping box to the whimsical paper wrappers on each roll, every component is recyclable or compostable. However, the most compelling reason for many to choose this brand is its social mission. The company donates an incredible 50% of its profits to non-profit partners working to build toilets and improve sanitation in developing countries. This transforms a mundane purchase into a meaningful contribution to global health and dignity. When you buy this toilet paper, you’re not just getting a high-quality, eco-friendly product; you’re funding a project that saves lives. For us, and for many users, this mission elevates the product from a simple commodity to a purchase we can feel genuinely good about making.
Design, Aesthetics, and the “Shrinkflation” Controversy
You can’t review this product without discussing its iconic design. The individually wrapped rolls are conversation starters. They add a pop of color and personality to a bathroom, turning a utilitarian object into a piece of decor. We loved being able to stack them in an open basket without creating an eyesore. This aesthetic appeal is a frequently praised attribute, with users calling the wrapping “adorable,” “sassy,” and “the most original idea” for a bathroom upgrade.
However, we must address a significant concern raised by loyal customers: shrinkflation. Several long-term subscribers have reported that recent batches feature rolls that are noticeably smaller, either in width, height, or both, while the price has remained the same or increased. One user expressed this frustration clearly: “I’ve had this on subscribe and save for a while and all of a sudden I get an order where the rolls are much smaller… Why am I paying a lot more for less product?” This is a valid and serious criticism. While the 330-sheet count per roll is still generous, any reduction in product size for the same price feels deceptive and erodes customer trust. While we didn’t have older rolls to compare side-by-side, this consistent feedback is a crucial factor for potential buyers to consider, especially those prioritizing cost per sheet above all else. It’s a disappointing cloud hanging over an otherwise stellar product, and one we hope the company addresses with transparency. You can explore the product’s full dimensions and recent user feedback before making a decision.
What Other Users Are Saying
Scouring feedback from a wide range of users, a clear picture emerges. The vast majority of customers are incredibly enthusiastic, primarily celebrating the trifecta of performance, aesthetics, and mission. A common theme is the “win-win” nature of the product. As one person summarized, “I honestly bought this mainly as a back up TP for guests. The wrapping and little slogans are super cute. The toilet paper itself is great too, very soft and durable! Definitely a win win all the way around.” Another echoed the sentiment about its skin-friendly properties, stating it is “Always reliable, very long lasting and soft… doesn’t deposit loose fluff and dust and I’m not allergic too it.”
However, the praise is not universal, and the criticism is consistent. The most prominent negative feedback centers on the perceived reduction in roll size. A disappointed customer noted, “I have used WGAC premium tp for a long time… This order I noticed the roll is much smaller but the cost is the same. This seems deceitful and is disappointing.” Others find the softness lacking compared to mainstream luxury brands or feel the price is too high, with one reviewer stating it was “a very overpriced item” after comparing it to a supermarket brand. This feedback confirms our assessment: it’s a fantastic product for a specific consumer, but concerns over value and softness are valid points of hesitation for others.
How Does Who Gives A Crap Compare to Traditional Options?
To truly understand the value and positioning of the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper, it’s essential to see how it stands against some of the most common alternatives on the market. We’ve compared it to three distinct types of products, each serving a different customer need.
1. Boardwalk 96-Roll Bulk 2-Ply Bathroom Toilet Paper
- Individually wrapped, soft, two-ply, textured, perforated toilet tissue.
- Embossed, standard size toilet paper roll.
- Economical, reliable and septic safe.
The Boardwalk offering represents the ultimate in budget and bulk purchasing. Aimed at commercial settings or extremely price-sensitive households, its primary selling point is the sheer quantity for the cost. However, the trade-offs are significant. It is a standard 2-ply, wood-pulp paper that offers none of the softness, strength, or eco-friendly benefits of the Who Gives A Crap paper. It lacks the hypoallergenic properties, the plastic-free packaging, and the powerful social mission. Someone might prefer Boardwalk if their only purchasing criterion is the lowest possible cost per sheet for a high-traffic bathroom, and they have no concerns about material sustainability or skin sensitivity.
2. Cottonelle Professional Bulk Toilet Paper 48 Rolls
- 170 Sheets/Roll; 48 Rolls of Cottonelle Professional Ultra CleanCare Standard Roll Bulk Toilet Paper; 8,160 Sheets/Case; Clean Ripple Design; White
- Cottonelle Ultra CleanCare features our CleaningRipples Texture for a refreshing clean
- This premium commercial toilet paper makes a great impression on your employees and visitors
Cottonelle Professional occupies a middle ground. It’s a recognized brand name that offers a more consistent and slightly higher quality experience than a generic bulk option like Boardwalk. It’s designed for reliability in professional or large-family settings. While it’s a step up in quality, it is still a conventional, tree-based product that relies on traditional manufacturing processes. It does not offer the unique sustainable advantages of bamboo, nor does it come with the plastic-free packaging or ethical mission of Who Gives A Crap. A consumer who values brand familiarity and is looking for a dependable, no-frills option in bulk might choose Cottonelle, but they would be forgoing the significant environmental and social benefits.
3. Charmin Ultra Soft Mega Roll Toilet Paper 12 Count
- 75% more absorbent, and you can use up to 4X less (vs. the leading bargain brand)
- Unique comfort cushions give you even more of the comforting softness you and your family will love
- Clog-safe and septic-safe; unscented
Charmin Ultra Soft is the champion of plushness and the direct competitor on the single metric of softness. If your goal is to have the most pillowy, luxurious-feeling toilet paper available, Charmin is the market leader. However, this comfort comes at a significant environmental cost. It is made from virgin forest fibers, contributes to deforestation, and comes wrapped in plastic. It is often treated with chemicals to achieve its signature softness, which can be irritating to sensitive skin. A user would choose Charmin over Who Gives A Crap if softness is their one and only priority, and they are willing to overlook the environmental impact and potential for skin irritation. In contrast, the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper offers a more balanced, responsible form of quality.
Our Final Verdict: Is Who Gives A Crap the Right Choice For You?
After extensive testing and analysis, we can confidently say that the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper is an outstanding product that successfully delivers on its promises. It is strong, effective, lint-free, and fantastic for sensitive skin. It redefines bathroom essentials by injecting sustainability, social responsibility, and vibrant design into a category that has been stagnant for decades. It proves that you don’t have to choose between a quality product and a clear conscience.
That said, it is not for everyone. If you are a “softness maximalist” or a budget-driven buyer concerned about the recent reports of “shrinkflation,” you may want to look elsewhere. But if you are an eco-conscious consumer who wants a reliable, skin-friendly toilet paper from a company that is actively making the world a better place, this is, without a doubt, the product for you. It’s a purchase that feels good, looks good, and does good. For us, that’s a combination that’s more than worth it. If you’re ready to make a simple change in your home that has a major positive impact, we highly recommend you give the Who Gives A Crap 24 Rolls 3 Ply Bamboo Toilet Paper a try.
Last update on 2025-11-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API